Auto Accidents

West Virginia Passenger injured in ATV Accident not covered under uninsured motorist statute

By The Wolfe Law Firm2 min readUpdated: October 2026 | Reviewed by Legal Team

The West Virginia Supreme Court reversed an Order of Circuit Court of Brooke County holding that an automobile insurance policy excluding an off-road ATV from uninsured motorist coverage does not provide coverage where a passenger was injured while riding off road ATV.

Nationwide all-terrain vehicle crashes in 2006 totaled more than 500 deaths with 20 percent of that number being children. West Virginia, along with Pennsylvania, California, Texas and Kentucky reported the highest number of ATV deaths since 1982. Most of the deaths and injuries are to children resulted from them riding on adult-size ATVs.

The West Virginia Court recognized in the recent case that the primary purpose of mandatory uninsured motorist coverage is to protect innocent victims from the hardships caused by negligent, financially irresponsible drivers.

However, the Court denied uninsured motorist coverage for this accident where a passenger of an ATV vehicle, that was being driven off road, upholding the automobile insurance policy exclusion. The West Virginia Supreme Court found that the exclusion does not violate the intent and purpose of the uninsured motorist statute at West Virginia Code Section 33-6-31(b).

Since ATV's are not required to have a license and registration in West Virginia, they are not required to have motorist liability insurance coverage pursuant to West Virginia Code Section 17D-4-2.

Citizens in West Virginia must not assume that their ATV will be covered under their Automobile policies and indeed the same exclusion found in this policy from State Farm Auto Insurance Company for ATV's is common in most automobile policies written in West Virginia.

You should review your policy and ask your insurance agent if ATV's are excluded and discuss purchasing coverage for your ATV.

Key Legal Takeaways & Summary

Essential West Virginia Legal Principles Established in This Case:

  • •This analysis of "West Virginia Passenger injured in ATV Accident not covered under uninsured motorist statute" highlights the essential legal protections and obligations established under West Virginia civil and statutory law.
  • •Under West Virginia's modified comparative negligence framework (W. Va. Code § 55-7-13a), an injured motorist may recover damages provided their degree of fault does not exceed 50%.
  • •Preserving physical evidence—including vehicle electronic data recorder (EDR) logs, witness statements, and accident reconstruction data—is vital immediately following a collision.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions and legal analysis regarding claims under West Virginia law:

What steps should I take immediately after a motor vehicle accident in West Virginia?

Seek prompt medical attention, ensure law enforcement completes an official crash investigation report, document scene photographs, and avoid providing recorded statements to insurance adjusters before consulting counsel.

How does comparative fault affect car accident settlements in West Virginia?

West Virginia follows the 51% bar rule: if a driver is determined to be 20% at fault, their total damages are reduced by 20%. If they are found 51% or more responsible, recovery is completely barred.

Injured in West Virginia?

Don't wait to get the legal representation you deserve. Contact our experienced attorneys today for a free case evaluation.

Call (800) 559-8765